The police did not pursue or raise an alarm. They did not call the sheriff. They made no move to save Austin Callaway. The next morning a passerby found him on a road several miles outside town, bleeding to death from gunshot wounds to the hands, arms and head. He died a few hours later.
The word lynching refers to any murder carried out by a group acting outside the law but with expectation of impunity. (It is not just death by hanging.) That definition fits Callaway’s death exactly. Police did not protect Callaway. They also failed to pursue the lynchers or investigate his death. There was no autopsy. There was no grand jury inquiry. In addition, the police chief faced no critical questions from the press or City Council. Giving assent by their silence, most white civic and religious leaders failed to speak out to condemn the lynching.
Meanwhile, the African American community did call for justice. Reverend L.W. Strickland, the pastor at Warren Temple, led mass meetings and helped charter the first local chapter of the NAACP. It was to no avail. In late October, Strickland wrote Thurgood Marshall, concluding, “[The city has] settled the matter by ignoring it.”